The best chicken pot pie maker overall in this roundup is the Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker, a practical pick for making several individual pies at once. The Sunbeam Pie Magic is the standout for shoppers who want a dedicated pie-making format, while the FineMade model pairs pocket pies with a crust cutter for shaping dough. The main tradeoffs are batch size, pie style, and how much hands-on dough preparation each appliance involves. Mini pie and quiche makers can handle individual portions, but their cavity size may not suit every appetite or recipe. Read on for the full comparison and guidance on choosing a model that fits your kitchen and cooking habits.
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker ranks first for its balance of multi-pie capacity and straightforward appeal for individual chicken pot pies.
- The Sunbeam Pie Magic serves a different purpose from the mini models: it is the dedicated pie-style alternative rather than another compact pie-and-quiche appliance.
- Most of the lineup is built around mini portions, so shoppers who want one larger meal should check cavity dimensions and serving expectations before choosing.
- FineMade’s included crust cutter is a practical differentiator for buyers who want help shaping dough, though it does not remove the need to prepare fillings and assemble pies.
- MasterChef, Aoruru, and CucinaPro overlap as mini pie and quiche makers; compare their size, controls, and cleanup details rather than assuming the category label means identical results.
| Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red |  | Best for Guided Mini-Pie Prep | Brand: Sunbeam | Model: FPSBPMM980 | Capacity: 4 pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best for Batch-Making Small Pies | Capacity: 6 mini pies or quiches | Mini pie diameter: 2.75 inches | Product dimensions: 2 x 10 x 4 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best Compact Pick for Simple Batches | Brand: Aoruru | Capacity: 4 bite-size pies or quiches | Wattage: 800 watts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker |  | Best for Versatile Quick Pies | Brand: Sunbeam | Model: 4805 | Wattage: 1000 watts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter |  | Best for Larger Individual Pocket Pies | Brand: FineMade | Capacity: Up to 3 pocket pies | Pocket pie size: 4.5 x 2.5 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best for Making Six Small Pies at Once | Brand: CucinaPro | Capacity: Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts | Included component: Pie tin | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| chicken pot pie maker | Brand | Capacity | Wattage | Voltage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker | Sunbeam | 4 pies | 1400 watts | 100 volts |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | — | 6 mini pies or quiches | — | — |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Q | Aoruru | 4 bite-size pies or quiches | 800 watts | 110 volts |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker | Sunbeam | — | 1000 watts | — |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket | FineMade | Up to 3 pocket pies | — | 120 volts |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | CucinaPro | Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts | 980 W | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red
The Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker suits cooks who want a small batch of individual pot pies without shaping every crust by eye. Its four cavities make fewer pies per batch than the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker, but the included pastry cutter and pie press give you tools for sizing and forming the dough. That can make repeat batches more consistent, especially when preparing savory fillings alongside dessert pies or quiches. Power and ready-to-bake lights also provide a basic cue for when to start, rather than leaving you to guess whether the appliance has heated. The tradeoff is the mini format: it cannot produce a full-size family pie, and its plastic construction may feel less substantial than a metal-bodied option.
Pros:- Makes four mini pies at once
- Includes pastry-cutting and pie-press tools for shaping dough
- Nonstick cooking plates support easier food release
- Power and ready-to-bake indicator lights offer a simple heat cue
Cons:- Cavities are limited to mini pies rather than family-size portions
- Plastic construction may feel less substantial than metal alternatives
Best for: Home cooks who want four individual pot pies per batch and value included tools for shaping pastry.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs a single large pot pie or wants to make more than four portions in one batch.
- Brand:Sunbeam
- Model:FPSBPMM980
- Capacity:4 pies
- Wattage:1400 watts
- Voltage:100 volts
- Weight:7.2 pounds
- Material and coating:Plastic with nonstick cooking plates
- Included accessories:Pastry cutting tool and pie press tool
Our verdict“Choose this Sunbeam if you want four formed mini pies with dough-shaping tools and clear basic heating indicators.”
MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
Capacity is the MasterChef’s main advantage: it makes six 2.75-inch pies or quiches at once, more than the four-pie Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker or the four-pie Aoruru. For hosts serving a tray of small savory bites, that extra pair of cavities can reduce the number of batches. The dough-cutting circle helps portion pastry to fit, and the included manual supplies recipes and instructions for cooks who want a starting point. Nonstick interiors also make release and cleanup more straightforward. The compromise is size: 2.75-inch pies are better suited to tasting portions or snacks than a substantial chicken pot pie meal. Choose another model if you want larger individual pockets, such as the FineMade, or fewer but more meal-like pies.
Pros:- Makes six mini pies or quiches at once
- Dough-cutting circle helps portion pastry for the cavities
- Nonstick interior supports easier food release and cleanup
- Manual includes instructions and recipes
Cons:- 2.75-inch pies are small for a main-meal serving
- Small cavity size limits the amount of filling each pie can hold
Best for: Hosts and meal-preppers who want to make six very small pies or quiches in each batch.
Not ideal for: People looking for filling single-serving chicken pot pies; the 2.75-inch cavities make small portions.
- Capacity:6 mini pies or quiches
- Mini pie diameter:2.75 inches
- Product dimensions:2 x 10 x 4 inches
- Item weight:4.29 pounds
- Interior:Nonstick
- Included accessories:Dough-cutting circle and manual with recipes
- Model number:MTF-MPB-740
Our verdict“Pick the MasterChef when batch count matters more than portion size and you want six small pies ready at once.”
Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
The Aoruru is a straightforward choice for cooks who want a compact appliance for four bite-size pies or quiches and do not need adjustable settings. Its 800-watt design and single setting keep operation simple, while the nonstick surface is intended to make cleanup easier after savory fillings. Compared with the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker, it makes two fewer pieces per batch, but its compact design may suit kitchens where storage space matters more than maximum output. The product data also identifies the coating as lead-free, PFAS-free, and PFOA-free. That said, bite-size capacity limits its usefulness for full meal portions, and the plastic construction plus one-setting operation offer less flexibility than buyers seeking more control over how their crusts bake.
Pros:- Makes up to four bite-size pies or quiches at once
- Compact design is convenient for storage
- Nonstick coating is intended to ease cleanup
- Coating is listed as lead-free, PFAS-free, and PFOA-free
Cons:- Single setting provides no stated temperature or time adjustment
- Plastic construction may be less robust than metal-bodied options
- Bite-size portions are limited for main-meal pot pies
Best for: Apartment cooks who want a small, easy-to-store maker for occasional bite-size savory pies and quiches.
Not ideal for: Families making meal-sized pot pies or cooks who want adjustable temperature or cooking-time settings.
- Brand:Aoruru
- Capacity:4 bite-size pies or quiches
- Wattage:800 watts
- Voltage:110 volts
- Settings:1
- Material:Plastic
- Coating:Nonstick; listed as lead-free, PFAS-free, and PFOA-free
- Warranty:Limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose the Aoruru for compact storage and simple four-piece batches, but skip it if you need larger portions or cooking controls.”
Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker
The Sunbeam Pie Magic stands out for cooks who want one appliance for pot pies, fruit pies, quiche, and even pizza. It is described as baking pies in 10 minutes or less, making it a practical fit for quick small-batch meals rather than elaborate pastry projects. Its 1000-watt design, nonstick coating, and two included dough cutters cover the basics, while the cord wrap helps keep storage tidier. Compared with the four-cavity Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker, the Pie Magic is presented as a compact pie maker without a stated four-pie capacity, so buyers should not assume the same batch output. Its single setting also limits control; the MasterChef offers more explicitly defined multi-pie capacity if serving count is the priority.
Pros:- Described as baking pies in 10 minutes or less
- Handles pot pies, fruit pies, quiche, and pizza
- Includes two dough cutters
- Compact design includes a cord wrap for storage
Cons:- Only one setting is specified
- Capacity is not stated, making batch planning less clear than with the MasterChef
- Polycarbonate construction may not appeal to buyers seeking an all-metal appliance
Best for: Cooks who want a compact appliance for quick pot pies and occasional fruit pies, quiche, or pizza.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a clearly specified multi-pie capacity or adjustable cooking settings.
- Brand:Sunbeam
- Model:4805
- Wattage:1000 watts
- Settings:1
- Dimensions:9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches
- Weight:4 pounds
- Material and coating:Polycarbonate with nonstick coating
- Included components:Two dough cutters
Our verdict“Pick the Pie Magic for a compact, quick-cooking appliance that can handle several kinds of pies, not for a defined high-capacity batch.”
FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter
The FineMade makes a different tradeoff from the round’s small-cavity makers: it produces up to three pocket pies, each measuring 4.5 x 2.5 inches. That lower batch count than the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker is offset by a more substantial pocket format that better suits a snack or light meal. The included crust cutter helps prepare evenly sized pastry, and the compact 9.5-inch-square body is easier to store than a larger countertop appliance. Its stainless-steel material and nonstick coating distinguish it from plastic options such as the Aoruru. The limitation is control: no temperature or cooking-time settings are specified, so buyers have less guidance for adjusting results. It also remains a small-pocket appliance, not a maker for full-size chicken pot pies.
Pros:- Makes up to three pocket pies measuring 4.5 x 2.5 inches
- Included crust cutter helps prepare evenly sized pastry
- Stainless-steel construction distinguishes it from plastic-bodied choices
- Compact 9.5 x 9.5-inch footprint and nonstick surface support storage and cleanup
Cons:- Makes fewer pies per batch than the six-cavity MasterChef
- No temperature or cooking-time controls are specified
- Pocket size still falls short of a full-size pot pie
Best for: Cooks who prefer a few larger pocket pies for snacks or light meals and want a crust cutter included.
Not ideal for: Families wanting a high-volume batch or anyone who needs adjustable cooking controls and full-size pies.
- Brand:FineMade
- Capacity:Up to 3 pocket pies
- Pocket pie size:4.5 x 2.5 inches
- Power:750 watts
- Voltage:120 volts
- Dimensions:9.5 x 9.5 x 3.8 inches
- Material and coating:Stainless steel with nonstick coating
- Free of:BPA, PFOA, and PTFE
- Included accessory:Crust cutter
Our verdict“Choose the FineMade when larger individual pockets matter more than batch count, but look elsewhere for adjustable controls or family-size pies.”
CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
The CucinaPro’s standout advantage is capacity for up to six mini pies, making it a better fit for serving several individual portions at once than the Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker. Its included dough cutter helps size pastry for the cavities, while the PFAS-free nonstick ceramic interior is designed to ease release and cleanup after baking. At 4.2 pounds and roughly 10 inches across, it’s also a compact countertop appliance that can be put away between uses.
The tradeoff is scale: this is for mini pies, not a full-size chicken pot pie, so it won’t suit cooks who want one large centerpiece. The product listing also gives two different dimension measurements, which makes storage fit harder to judge. I’d choose it for batch-making small portions, but compare its stated six-pie capacity carefully with alternatives if cavity count is your priority.
Pros:- Bakes up to six mini pies, quiches, or tarts at once
- Includes a dough cutter for sizing pastry
- PFAS-free nonstick ceramic interior supports easier pastry release and cleanup
- Compact footprint and 4.2-pound weight make storage easier
Cons:- Makes only small individual portions, not a full-size chicken pot pie
- The description and listed item dimensions conflict, so exact storage fit is unclear
Best for: Cooks who want to make up to six individual chicken pot pies or other small savory pies in one batch and have limited storage space.
Not ideal for: Households that prefer one full-size pot pie or need reliable, consistent measurements before buying an appliance for a tightly fitted cabinet.
- Brand:CucinaPro
- Capacity:Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts
- Included component:Pie tin
- Special feature:PFAS-free nonstick coating
- Wattage:980 W
- Dimensions:10.5 × 4 × 10 inches in description; 2 × 10 × 4 inches in listed item dimensions
- Weight:4.2 pounds
- Color:White
Our verdict“Choose the CucinaPro if you want several small pot pies per batch and compact storage matters more than making a full-size pie.”
How We Picked
I ranked these six appliances around the job buyers actually want done: making chicken pot pies in a repeatable, manageable way at home. The main criteria were the format and number of pies each model can make, how well its design appears suited to savory fillings, ease of handling and cleanup, and useful extras such as a crust cutter. I also considered whether a model’s role is distinct enough to justify choosing it over another small pie-and-quiche maker.
The Sunbeam 4-Piece leads because its multi-pie format is a strong fit for individual servings without narrowing the choice to a single specialized feature. The Pie Magic earns a separate place for buyers drawn to a dedicated pie maker, while FineMade stands out for dough preparation support. The MasterChef, Aoruru, and CucinaPro models round out the list as mini pie-and-quiche options; their ranking depends on practical fit and differentiation, not on treating similar product labels as proof of equal capacity or performance. I did not assume unlisted specifications, so buyers should verify dimensions, controls, and care instructions before purchase.
| chicken pot pie maker | Brand | Material and coating |
|---|---|---|
| Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker | Sunbeam | Plastic with nonstick cooking plates |
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | — | — |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Q | Aoruru | — |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker | Sunbeam | Polycarbonate with nonstick coating |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket | FineMade | Stainless steel with nonstick coating |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | CucinaPro | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers
Choosing a chicken pot pie maker is less about finding the appliance with the most features and more about matching its format to your preferred portions, dough routine, and kitchen storage. These factors can prevent common mismatches that are easy to miss when product names sound similar.
Match the cavity size to the meal you want
Mini pie makers are designed around individual portions, but the word “mini” does not tell you exactly how much filling each cavity holds. Check the appliance dimensions and, when available, cavity measurements against the portion size you usually serve. A small cavity can work well for lunch or tasting portions but may feel limiting as a full dinner. Larger formats can reduce the number of batches, though they may take more counter and storage space. Avoid choosing from a product photo alone, since perspective can make cavities appear roomier than they are. If you regularly cook for several people, prioritize confirmed capacity over a long list of accessories.
Decide how much dough work you want to do
A pie maker cooks the assembled pie, but it does not necessarily prepare the crust or filling for you. Some buyers enjoy rolling and cutting pastry; others want accessories that simplify shaping. A cutter can make portions more consistent and reduce guesswork, but it will not roll dough, mix filling, or seal every pie automatically. Before paying extra for an accessory, ask whether it replaces a tool you already own or solves a task you find inconvenient. Store-bought pastry may save time, though you still need to check whether its size and thickness suit the appliance. The best fit depends on your preferred prep routine, not just the appliance’s cooking function.
Think through filling texture and moisture
Chicken pot pie filling is often wetter than sweet pie fillings, so recipe consistency matters. A very loose filling can make assembly messy and may challenge a small pastry cavity, regardless of the appliance. Use a thick, spoonable filling and leave enough room around the edge for the crust to close. Follow the maker’s instructions for filling quantity and cooking; overcrowding can interfere with sealing and even heating. Buyers who plan to adapt family recipes should expect a little recipe adjustment rather than assuming every filling transfers unchanged. This matters more for compact pocket formats, where a small excess can make a large difference.
Check cleanup and storage before choosing
Crumbs, gravy, and pastry fat can collect around hinges and plate edges, so cleanup is part of the everyday experience. Read the care instructions to learn whether cooking surfaces are removable and whether the manufacturer permits a particular cleaning method. Do not assume a nonstick surface means the whole appliance can be immersed or put in a dishwasher. Measure the appliance’s storage footprint and allow room for its lid and cord, especially if your cabinets are already crowded. A compact maker that is easy to put away may see more regular use than a larger model that stays on the counter. Also check whether the unit can be stored upright before relying on that to save space.
Choose between batch convenience and pie-style flexibility
Making several individual pies at once can simplify serving a family or preparing portions for different appetites. A dedicated pie format may appeal more to buyers who prioritize that style over a broader mini pie-and-quiche label. Neither approach is automatically better: batch appliances can limit pie size, while a more specialized design may offer fewer reasons to use it for other foods. Think about how often you will make savory pies compared with quiches or other pastry dishes. If chicken pot pie is an occasional meal, broader use may matter more than a narrowly focused design. If it is a regular favorite, a format that matches your preferred pie size may justify giving up some versatility.
Pay for practical fit, not a feature count
Extra accessories and multiple functions only add value when they suit the way you cook. A crust cutter is useful if you frequently shape pastry, while it may sit unused if you rely on pre-cut dough. A multi-purpose pie-and-quiche maker can earn its place in a small kitchen, but only if you expect to use those other functions. Compare the appliance’s confirmed dimensions, capacity, care requirements, and included tools before weighing its feature list. Buyers new to countertop pie makers may prefer a simple format with clear instructions over a model that adds accessories without reducing prep. Spend more when a specific design solves a recurring problem, not merely because a product claims more uses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a mini pie maker produce a full dinner-size chicken pot pie?
That depends on the cavity dimensions and the portion size you consider a full meal. Many mini pie makers are intended for individual pies, so they may make smaller servings than a conventional family-size pie dish. Check the manufacturer’s measurements and capacity details rather than relying on the word “mini” or the product image. If you need one large pie for several people, a compact multi-cavity format may not match that goal. For individual dinners, mini portions can be convenient, especially when paired with sides.
Do I need to cook the chicken filling before putting it in the pie maker?
Use the product instructions and a tested recipe to determine how filling should be prepared. Many appliance-style pie recipes call for cooked chicken and a prepared filling, since the maker’s cooking cycle may not be designed to cook raw meat safely through. A thick, fully cooked filling is also easier to portion into small pastry cavities. Avoid filling the pies with hot, runny mixture, which can make sealing difficult and create a mess. When adapting a recipe, follow safe food-handling guidance and confirm the filling reaches a safe serving temperature.
Is a pie-and-quiche maker a better buy than a dedicated pie maker?
It depends on whether you will use the appliance for more than chicken pot pies. A pie-and-quiche model may make more sense if you plan to prepare several types of savory or sweet individual dishes. A dedicated pie format can be a better match if you care most about that specific style and do not need broader use. Compare cavity size, batch capacity, and care instructions, since the product category alone does not answer those questions. Choose based on the meals you expect to make repeatedly, rather than hypothetical uses that may never become part of your routine.
Will refrigerated or frozen pastry work in these appliances?
Pastry compatibility varies with cavity shape, plate size, and the maker’s instructions. Refrigerated dough may be convenient, but you may need to trim it to fit the cooking surface and leave enough material for sealing. Frozen pastry should be thawed and handled as directed on its package and by the appliance maker; stiff dough can crack when shaped. Check whether included cutters are sized for the appliance before buying dough around them. A small test batch can help you adjust thickness and portion size before preparing a full meal.
What should I prioritize if I have limited counter and cabinet space?
Measure both the intended counter area and the cabinet space where you will store the appliance. A compact footprint is helpful, but the lid, cord, and any accessories also need a place. Check the full product dimensions and storage guidance rather than judging scale from photographs. If you expect to use the maker often, leaving it accessible may matter more than saving a small amount of cabinet space. For occasional use, a model that stores neatly and has fewer loose accessories may be easier to live with.
Conclusion
For most shoppers seeking individual chicken pot pies, I recommend the Sunbeam 4-Piece Pie Maker as the best overall because its multi-pie format suits a practical home batch. The MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker is my best value-style choice for buyers comparing straightforward mini pie functionality, while the Sunbeam Pie Magic is the best premium-style pick for those who prefer a dedicated pie-making option. Beginners may find the CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker a sensible starting point if its dimensions and care requirements fit their kitchen. For shoppers who want help shaping pastry, the FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter is the most specific match; Aoruru is another mini pie-and-quiche option to compare when checking available specifications. Before choosing, confirm capacity, cleaning directions, and storage fit so the maker matches the portions and routine you actually want.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
